The journey to buying your cruising boat is every bit as thrilling—and daunting—as casting off the lines for the first time. That’s why having someone like Captain Jay Williams in your corner makes all the difference. With a lifetime on the water, from running liveaboard dive vessels in the Bahamas to managing new builds in Italy and overseeing complex yacht projects worldwide, Jay brings uncommon technical expertise, calm leadership, and a deep commitment to his clients' best interests. His hands-on experience, problem-solving skill, and ethical approach ensure your purchase process is not only efficient and well-managed but also genuinely enjoyable as you take the next step toward your dream.

Captain Jay Williams
(305) 788-1121
About Jay Williams

The Structural Difference: Why Not All Catamarans Are Built For The Same Mission

Catamarans have come a long way. 20 years ago, they were odd ducks, restricted mostly to shallow water destinations and charter fleets. Today, catamarans make up a huge portion of new sailboat sales, and the charter model is one of the most popular ways to get into new catamaran ownership.

Manufacturing has exploded, with large manufacturers in South Africa and Europe meeting the need for a constant inflow of new boats destined for charter ownership. Entire ecosystems have sprung up around these boats, wherever charter boats are thriving.

Today, catamarans make up the bulk of the world cruising fleet. Influencers post their cat adventures, and many sailors wouldn’t even consider a monohull.

Pre owned, chartered cats are everywhere on the used market, tempting buyers with cruising dreams at low entry prices.

There is a growing gap between cats that are designed around the realities of charter service, and boats that are designed and built to log hard offshore miles.

Let’s take a look at today’s industry, digging deep into the reality of charter ownership of a new cat, buying a used charter cat or going for a boat that was designed around the realities of offshore cruising.

The Structural, Economic, and Long-Term Ownership Difference

At first glance, most modern sailing catamarans look similar at the dock. Wide beam. Expansive cockpit. Bright salon. Twin engines. Multiple cabins. All catamaran buyers want these attributes.

Take a closer look, though, and differences become apparent. These boats are not built to the same priorities.

There is a fundamental difference between a catamaran engineered for high-turnover charter service and one designed for serious offshore cruising. If your objective is extended passagemaking, structural integrity, offshore safety, and preserving long-term asset strength, that distinction matters.

This is not about criticizing charter boats. It is about understanding design intent — and aligning your purchase with your mission.

What “Built for Charter” Actually Means

The docks at the boat shows are full of these boats, with cheerful salespeople talking about income models and boat ownership. Charter-focused production catamarans are engineered around a specific economic model:

• High production volume

• Predictable manufacturing cost

• Maximum interior accommodation per foot

• Durable but cost-controlled materials

• Systems sized for short-term use

• Simplified fleet maintenance

This model works well for vacation fleets.

Serious cruising demands something different:

• Structural stiffness under offshore loading

• Weight discipline

• Reduced torsional flex

• Systems redundancy

• Long-term fatigue resistance

• Owner-focused layouts

The divergence begins at the drawing board.

Weight: The Multiplier That Changes Everything

Ppalu was making heavy weather. The Gulf Stream was kicking up, the wind clocking to the north with an approaching cold front, and the wave trains were stacking up under our hulls as we made for North Rock. She was heavily loaded for a charter season: crates of canned food, freezers packed, dive gear loaded onboard.

As the sea state increased, the waves exceeded the height of the bridgedeck and started to slam under the hull. Poor Ppalu slowed down: 4 knots, then 3, barely countering the Gulf Stream. Each wave impact shuddered her entire structure. The mast shivered and thrummed. We had to make Nassau for a charter, but it was not going to happen like this. I looked at the wind direction closely. Was there enough west to get us up to Northwest Providence Channel? Yes. Maybe. We shifted course for Great Issac, riding the Gulf Stream, sheeted in the jib and main and pounded our way north. Past Great Issac Light, we were able to turn more east, skimming the Hen and Chickens. We eased the sails onto a beam reach and got her moving again. That passage in an overloaded cat taught me a hard lesson: pay attention to weight.

Weight is one of the most consequential variables in catamaran design — and one of the least discussed in brokerage conversations.

In a monohull, weight contributes to stability.

In a catamaran, excess weight is almost always a liability.

Performance & Efficiency

Heavier catamarans:

• Accelerate more slowly

• Require more wind to reach target speeds

• Slam harder in short-period seas

• Load rigging and structure more aggressively

• Burn more fuel under power

Lighter, well-engineered platforms:

• Sail efficiently in moderate wind

• Reduce motion fatigue

• Impose less stress on rig and crossbeams

• Maintain higher average passagemaking speeds

Over a long offshore passage, average speed matters. A one-knot difference compounds into days.

Weight & Structural Load

Ppalu’s entire structure felt like she was coming apart, as stout as she was. The bridgedeck was taking the impact of the waves, which was distributed into her structure. It showed up everywhere, from broken eggs in the stores to the whole mast whipping.

Every additional pound increases:

• Torsional stress between hulls

• Crossbeam compression

• Rig compression loads

• Slamming force under the bridgedeck

Heavier boats experience higher impact energy when they meet waves.

That energy must be absorbed somewhere — typically in laminate, bulkheads, or structural joints.

Weight magnifies fatigue over time.

Weight & Offshore Capability

In deteriorating conditions, a lighter, properly engineered catamaran often:

• Rides higher

• Pounds less

• Recovers more quickly from wave impact

• Maintains better helm responsiveness

Excess displacement reduces the safety margin when conditions intensify.

Weight discipline is not about racing.

It is about preserving structural margins offshore.

The Production Reality

Charter-oriented boats often gain weight through:

• Heavier layups rather than engineered stiffness

• Volume-driven hull forms

• Dense interior build-outs

• Large tankage without weight optimization

• Standardized production hardware

This is not inherently flawed. But it shifts performance, motion, and long-term fatigue characteristics. Performance-focused cruising builders treat weight as a primary design variable — not an afterthought. In offshore sailing, weight is a multiplier. It amplifies either good engineering or its absence.

Where Manufacturer Cost Control Appears

Cost control in production charter-oriented boats is systematic.

Structural Engineering & Laminate Strategy 

High-volume production cats commonly use:

• Solid fiberglass laminate below the waterline

• Moderate reinforcement schedules

• Bulkhead tabbing optimized for assembly speed

• Heavier layups rather than engineered stiffness

• Limited advanced composite use

This approach is durable and predictable.

Performance-oriented cruising builders instead emphasize:

• Engineered laminate schedules

• Carbon reinforcement in high-load zones

• Integrated structural grids

• Weight optimization

• Precision bonding

Stiffness offshore is not about speed alone. It directly impacts fatigue resistance and safety margins.

Bridgedeck Clearance & Hull Design 

Few elements influence offshore comfort more than bridgedeck clearance.

Charter-oriented designs frequently prioritize interior volume. That often results in:

• Wider hulls

• Lower bridgedeck clearance

• Increased windage

• Higher displacement

In moderate conditions, this is manageable.

Offshore, reduced clearance can create:

• Repetitive slamming

• Increased torsional loading

• Crew fatigue

• Accelerated structural wear

Cruising- and performance-focused designs typically emphasize:

• Greater bridgedeck clearance

• Finer hull entries

• Improved weight distribution

• Reduced pounding

Hull geometry matters.

Volume-driven hulls maximize interior space but increase drag.

Narrower performance hulls:

• Move more efficiently

• Reduce motion fatigue

• Lower structural stress over distance

Offshore Safety: Engineering for the Conditions You Hope to Avoid

We were three days into the rally, a few hundred miles outside the Gulf Stream. The weather router advised us that a system was moving in with significant winds and seas. The fleet was mixed: heavy former-charter cats, a group of larger monohulls and some high performance cruising cats. Watching the satellite tracking was very instructive. The performance cats accelerated off the front of the weather, staying ahead of the worst, while the larger/faster monohulls and some of the lighter French cats cracked on sail to make the miles. The three groups diverged and kept on diverging all the way to the BVI. The fast cats were on anchor a few days before the bulk of the fleet made it in. They had a very different experience from the overloaded cats at the back, who got beat up in the front and

then fell out of the wind; the performance boats reported days of boisterous sailing under spinnaker while the rest of the group got caught.

The fast cat group was able to actively avoid the weather, flying code Zero sails while the slowest got hammered. They were safe by virtue of speed and planning.

Most catamarans are safe in fair weather.

The real test appears when conditions deteriorate.

Offshore safety results from structural stiffness, motion behavior, deck security, and redundancy.

Structural Load Management

Offshore sailing subjects a catamaran to:

• Torsional stress between hulls

• Crossbeam compression

• Rig load cycling

• Vertical impact

• Shear forces

A stiffer, lighter platform distributes and absorbs these forces more effectively.

Motion & Fatigue

Lower bridgedeck clearance and heavier displacement increase pounding and crew exhaustion.

Fatigue reduction is a safety factor.

Deck Layout & Watchkeeping

Offshore deck design should provide:

• Protected helm access

• Clear sightlines

• Secure movement

• Logical sail handling

• Strong handholds

Offshore sailing is conducted at night, tired, and sometimes in deteriorating conditions. Design matters.

Layout Philosophy: Volume vs Livability

“There’s no storage,” said Jack to his wife. We were looking at a French charter-style cat. “Where would we put the food for a longer cruise? On the beds up forward?”

Charter layouts prioritize berth count and revenue.

Cruising layouts prioritize:

• Storage

• Owner comfort

• Mechanical access

• Long-term livability

Owner’s Version Advantage

Non-charter cruising cats often offer:

• A dedicated master hull

• Generous storage

• Office or utility space

• Improved systems access

• Privacy and separation

Over months aboard, layout becomes mission-critical.

Lifespan: What Does This Boat Look like in 15-20 Years?

Working as a yard manager at a cat-specific yard, I had a front row seat to the decay of charter cats. By the time they were 15-20 years old, most of my customers’ boats were hammered. There were standouts, too: companies that had obviously put quality first. This absolutely paid off in the long run. It wasn’t just consumables, like sails or saildrives, but the actual structure of the boats that was much better. The stiffer hulls had much lower incidence of things coming loose. More sophisticated core materials did a better job of resisting water intrusion. Higher quality hatches and ports kept the interiors dry, while better designs of outdoor engine hatches led to longer lifespans of powertrain parts.

One really big area of concern I saw was the large sliding glass patio doors many manufacturers install at the back of the house. There’s a huge difference in both the quality of the doors themselves, and the structure surrounding them. The guilty shall remain unnamed, but when you encounter a door that won’t slide closed, look at the deck above for sag.

Fatigue appears gradually:

• Interior tabbing cracks

• Door misalignment

• Window seal leaks

• Structural softening

Charter boats with high turnover accumulate wear differently than privately owned cruising cats. Maintenance manages wear. It does not reverse fatigue. Longevity is about structural tightness and economic defensibility.

The Economics of Charter Programs

Before committing to any charter program purchase, take a hard look at the numbers. Ask yourself: “Do I want to get a heavily used boat in a few years in exchange for a discounted financing rate? Will I have the time to take advantage of the charter benefits offered by the company, or would I be better served by buying a boat outright and having access to it locally?”

Many charter boats, upon exiting the original program by a premium operator, move into a second-tier charter operation rather than to their owner’s hands, in order to continue to defray the costs of ownership. The business model of these second-tier businesses is simple: charge less to guests, provide the same experience, cut costs wherever you can. This results in the boats aging more rapidly. After the second-tier company is done with the boat, it goes into the used market and sells for whatever its condition and age allow.

If you’re interested in cruising, but can’t quite make the costs of a new boat make sense, we suggest looking in the used market for a boat you can afford, ideally an owner’s version of a cruising-optimized cat, or a boat leaving a first-tier charter operation in good condition if you accept the design limitations of a charter-optimized build.

Charter Financials

Charter revenue is sold on a gross-income model. Ownership outcome is net to you.

Purchase: $1,000,000 Gross revenue per year: $220,000

Expenses: Management (25%): $55,000 Dockage: $40,000 Maintenance: $50,000 Insurance: $25,000

Net before depreciation: ~$50,000

Depreciation on a new charter cat can exceed 10% per year, in the case of a $1 million boat, $100,000

Net loss: $50,000

Accelerated wear and resale impact erode long-term gains. The harder the boat works, the faster it ages.

Post-Hurricane Inventory & Storm-Damaged Boats

Greg tapped on my office door. “Hey, can you come look at something? I found a weird crack.” I grabbed my sounding hammer and headed out to the boat.

There was a crack along the base of the corridor leading forward towards the bow from the front door. It radiated strangely for a non-stressed area. I tapped and found delaminated core there, so I started investigating inside the lockers. Looking under a water tank, I saw seaweed. I reached in and found a handful of sand. A tap test showed extensive delamination in the anchor locker and generator spaces. We later found the hulls were separating and the sacrificial keels didn’t fit, they were not from the manufacturer. There was sand everywhere we looked: under sump boxes, between bulkheads. This boat had been full of sand and seawater at some point, and had sat in the Caribbean sun and cooked while it waited for a rescue. The pre-purchase surveyor had not caught it. A second survey totaled the boat. Greg’s cruising dreams ended right there.

After major storm seasons, storm-damaged inventory enters the brokerage market.

Not all repaired boats are problematic.

But buyers should carefully review:

• Repair documentation

• Moisture readings

• Engine submersion history

• Electrical corrosion

• Structural repairs

Structural compromise is rarely visible at the dock. Pay attention to the storm cycle: 6-12 months after a big Caribbean hurricane strike, there will be repaired charter boats trickling

into the US market. A proper repair can mean a great value. A poor, or hidden, repair is a tickling time bomb.

More than anything else, get a professional survey done as part of your diligence, for any boat. Remember, the choice of surveyor is yours and yours alone.

New Builds & Experienced Guidance

Selecting the right catamaran requires understanding how boats age.

Having managed multiple shipyards — including a catamaran-focused yard — provides direct experience with:

• Structural repairs

• Laminate failures

• Rig load consequences

• Electrical installation quality

• Long-term fatigue patterns

Specification decisions made during a new build determine decades of outcome.

Premium Manufacturers of Cruising Cats

These boats are rarely chartered, except in exclusive settings with paid crew. They’re usually designed around the real world requirements of safe, fast passagemaking. David Walters Yachts specializes in helping buyers work with high quality cruising boats. We can help you source a boat, new or used, from these or another manufacturer. This list is by no means comprehensive; there are lots of companies making small volume cruising cats.

HH

At David Walters Yachts, we love HH cats. Built in Taiwan by Hudson, these boats represent the highest quality we’ve seen in the space. From advanced composite åconstruction to incredible interior woodwork, a HH is a showpiece that can quickly cross

oceans and go anywhere. We see HH boats holding together well as they age too. HH boats have the best residual value, materials, customer service and overall quality we’ve seen. They’re comparable to the Hylas boats we have sold so many of over our history. Want the best? Buy a HH. We’d love to help you with it.

Sunreef

Built in Poland, Sunreef has one of the most advanced composite construction facilities on Earth. They tend towards boats over 60 feet and all boats are custom orders. David Walters Yachts has a custom Sunreef 70 in build for 2027 delivery. Throughout any Sunreef and great gear selections.

Balance

No conversation about performance cruising cats is complete without mentioning Balance. Built in South Africa, Balance builds boats in two different facilities: 2 Oceans builds their smaller boats, while St. Francis builds larger Balance models and the carbon composite lines. Overall, Balance boats, while comfortable and well designed, aren’t focused on the charter-ready social spaces. They’re made to go to sea and work there. Systems are simple and robust.

Gunboat

Currently built in France, Gunboat inhabits the bleeding edge of catamaran performance. Want the fastest, newest tech? Gunboat. They don’t put as much effort into creature comfort as some others: light weight and speed are paramount. Gunboat will take risks in service of the fastest offshore cat they can make.

The Bottom Line

A charter boat can circle the globe.

But a catamaran engineered for serious cruising will do so with:

• Better weight discipline

• Greater structural stiffness

• Safer offshore behavior

• More livable owner layouts

• Longer structural lifespan

• Stronger resale positioning

They may look similar at the dock. They are not built for the same mission.

A Conversation Worth Having

If your objective is serious cruising — offshore capability, structural longevity, and asset preservation — the starting platform matters.

At David Walters Yachts, the focus is on:

• Purpose-built performance cruising catamarans

• Select, privately owned, structurally sound cruising cats

• Platforms engineered for offshore longevity

In serious cruising, the right platform is not an upgrade. It is the foundation.